by PhotoMann
PhotoMann and Roongnapa explored and experienced
rural China (Yunnan province) in September 1997. It was a good trip
(mostly). We flew into Kunming from Bangkok about a week ago. It was
10 days of sensory overload. We spent a day in the Kunming area before
hitting the road to Zhongdian in the Dingin Tibetan Autonomous Prefecture
of Yunnan Province. It was a 2 day road trip to get there. We stayed
overnight in Dali. The main event (purpose of our trip) was to attend
the Kanba Art Festival. After the festival we hit the road again eventually
working our way back to Kunming. Overall we saw 1000 miles of rural
China by bumpy road!
The Kanba Art Festival, which occurs once every three
years (at different locations) is one of the most important events for
the Tibetan people. Tibetans come from all corners of the region. Some
travel 1,000 km to attend. Estimates put the attendance at the opening
ceremony was estimated to be 70-100 thousand. Roongnapa and I were 2
of about a dozen that were not Chinese or Tibetan.
The opening ceremony was incredible. It lasted 4 hours
and showcased a couple dozen different Tibetan tribes/groups (not sure
what word to use). Many wore their most ornate costumes and most groups
demonstrated traditional dances. In the afternoon we saw acrobatic horse
riding and horse racing. In the evening we went to a cultural show.
There were additional events as well. For all of this we had Chinese
press passes thanks to our tour company which was also supporting the
provincial TV network and others who required them. With the press pass
we could go anywhere even behind the scenes to see what was going on.
The festivities gave me the opportunity to shoot more slides than ever
before. I set a new record of 16 rolls in one day!
Here are some of the other highlights and observations
during our journey:
- We arranged the entire trip electronically.... via
the Internet and fax. When we arrived we were a little apprehensive
about what would await us. We were greeted by a Frank and Jack (their
English names). Frank was the guide who could speak English well and
Jack was the driver who spoke no English. All looked good till the 4
wheel drive vehicle broke down half way from the airport to their office.
We had to take a taxi to the office. Fortunately that was the only vehicle
problem for the trip.
- You can't get a cold drink in Yunnan if your life
depended on it! Everything including Coke and beer is consumed at room
temperature. They have refrigeration but don't use it for drinks. On
rare occasions there was consumable ice at the fancy places.
- We got stuck in a traffic jam at Yon Sou for more
than two hours. This happens on a daily basis thanks to the local market
which makes sure there isn't enough room for two lanes of traffic to
get through. The result is gridlock causing backups for many miles.
There are no alternate roads. Of course the jam eventually clears when
the locals have sold enough stuff for the day. The police do nothing.
- I shot a total of 55 rolls of slides during the
10 days including the 16 on the festival opening day. Some of you may
be shocked by this but it's not uncommon. I, as many photographers do,
live by the motto "film is cheap". It's much cheaper to throw away the
slides that didn't work out than going back to try again. In many cases
a shot may be once in a lifetime opportunity. I typically shoot varying
perspectives and exposures to increase the probability of a perfect
shot. It's especially hard with action shots where you don't know what
was actually captured till the slides return.
- While standing around an Yon Sou I met a Dutch man
who is growing tulips in Zhongdian. It turns out Zhongdian has a perfect
climate to grow tulips. They hope to eventually supply tulips regionally
from this Chinese base which is much cheaper than in Holland.
- Yunnan province has 25 different ethnic ("minority"
is the Chinese term) cultures within. There's incredible diversity going
from town to town. It's interesting to note that the "minorities" are
exempt from the one child policy. They can have two (5 years apart)
in an effort to increase their dwindling numbers.
- In Kunming some 'enterprising' individuals routinely
break bottles or lay glass at key intersections. The key is the proximity
of their bicycle tire repair businesses!
- In Yunnan their wine should be renamed fire water.
It's powerful stuff! We were obligated to toast with this on several
occasions.
- Food has been generally good but there are some
thing I'm not even willing to try (Roongnapa wouldn't either) like caterpillar
fungus soup. It was one of 20 courses at one banquet we attended for
photographers at the festival. In general most food is spicy. Steamed
rice is the only sure bet for not being spicy. Breakfasts are noodles
(spicy), sometimes dumplings, wet rice (soup)..... thank god for the
granola bars I packed.
- We usually had to ask for rice with meals... they
consider rice to be food for poor people. It's a filler when there isn't
enough other food.
- Zhongdian we had a "Hot Pot" dinner which consisted
of a boiling caldron over a flame in the middle of the table. It's kind
of like a Chinese version of Fondue. Just throw all the raw stuff in
and then try to fish out the cooked vegetables, meat, etc with your
chopsticks. It's a real test of your chopsticks skill level. If you
can't fish out the food you can go hungry (unless you get help from
those who might take pity on you). I did fairly well but some slick
items had to be stabbed to get out!
- Pollution in the cities is really bad. There is
constantly a cloud over Kunming which I though was bad until we arrived
in Jin Jang toward the end of our trip. Jin Jang is a center for steel,
iron and coal.... put it all together and you have a real mess!
- The 'scenic' toilet is a much better option than
any public toilet. A majority of public toilets were downright disgusting.
Searching for a bush or tree to hide behind is much better. All facilities
except for those in nice hotel rooms were at best a hole in the floor....
no sit-down toilets to be found :-(.
- Part of the time we traveled around with an LA based
travel writer that specializes in China. Fred Ma is also a chief photographer
for Chinese World Television and a freelance reporter for a Taiwan newspaper.
It was interesting to see how he worked.
- It also made me stand out in the crowd so to speak.
I was interviewed by Shanghai TV and showed up on the ceremony broadcast
for other stations. A friend in Bangkok said I was on CNN there for
about 10 seconds during a news clip. I haven't seen any of it.... I'm
working on trying to get a copy of the broadcast tape. The only problem
is the inability to mail out video tapes from China. There are a couple
of folks who might hand carry out a copy for me in a couple of months.
- We took candy and pens to give to kids during our
travels. On one occasion Roongnapa made the mistake of giving candy
to a couple of kids just outside a village school. In a flash, dozens
of kids were running out surrounding her. She gave out her whole stash
for the day in no time. It was actually quite amusing (to me and the
guide anyway).
- Roongnapa was cold much of the trip since out lowest
altitude for the trip was 5,000 feet. The days were warm when the sun
was out but the evenings were quite cool especially in Zhongdian which
is above 10,000 feet. Most of the time we were above 10,000 feet with
the surrounding peaks reaching 15-17,000 feet.
- There was only one souvenir that I really wanted
during the trip but decided to pass on it when I found out the store
was trying to gouge me. It was an ornate Tibetan knife. When our guide
asked to look at it he was told the price was about $10. As soon as
they saw I was the one interested in it the price suddenly was 'wrong'.
It was changed to $100 (10x increase!).
- We visited a couple Buddhist monasteries during
our journeys. They were quite interesting including an isolated one
with only one lama. There were no students so the future of this remote
monastery with over 800 years of history is in doubt.
- I carried my notebook computer on our journey to
do class assignments which would be due during the trip. The only problem
was getting on the Internet to post them and get e-mail out. The travel
company had indicated that Internet access would be available while
in China. They just didn't say how easy it would be. It turned out to
be a major hassle. There was one cyber cafe in Dali but we were only
there on the second night of our trip. The rest of the time was frustrating
at best. Even my backup plan of making an international call to the
US or Japan was extremely difficult since direct dialing an international
call wasn't available in any hotel rooms. When I inquired about dialing
out from the room I was told it was "quite impossible". I could theoretically
do an operator assisted call but didn't even try. Just think about trying
to get an operator to place a call to a carrier tone. Even if they would
do it by the time I could try to connect the ISP would have timed out.
In the end I was able to get on the net once from Li Jang by putting
my notebook on the hotel front desk and plugging directly into their
switchboard. Two failed attempts and an eventual 10 minute connection
cost me $41!
- In Zhongdian we went on a hike that nearly killed
me... at least that's how it felt at the time. The 'walk' to see a lake
turned out to be a 3 hour climb up (2 hours down) a rocky trail, across
wet marsh areas and up streams. This climb was from 10,000 to 12,000
feet. My lungs just couldn't suck up enough oxygen. I normally walk
all day in cities taking pictures w/o any problems. This was probably
the low light of the trip. Roongnapa was the smart one. She turned back
after only 10 minutes. She took a nap in the Toyota Cruiser while we
'hiked'.
- We visited a couple Tibetan homes near Zhongdian.
They were quite big even by western standards. Each one had a central
kitchen with a wood burning stove. The smoke was vented through the
attic to the outside. One house was built over a livestock pen so it
provided protection for some of the animals in the winter.
- A fairly common mode of transport was made from
what looked like modified roto-tillers (the kind with rear blades).
There were no blades. The 'vehicle' typically towed a trailer which
could carry a phenomenal amount of stuff (or people). The engines are
cold water cooled. As the cooling water boils off they add more water.
- Bicycles are everywhere especially in the cities.
They're oblivious to cars and pedestrians. They get nailed a lot because
they just don't look. When walking you have to be careful not be run
into by the hordes of bikes.
- The scenery in the countryside was spectacular.
I felt like crying on a couple of days when the landscape was picture
perfect but the weather prevented any worthwhile shooting.
- Rice was growing everywhere at lower altitudes.
Above 8,000 feet barley appeared to be more prevalent. There were lots
of plots terraced into hill sides as well.
- There was a great amount of heavy work done by hand.
We saw very few heavy machines. - The Chinese like menthol flavored
mineral water.... I think it's nasty stuff!
- We attended an interesting traditional Chinese Naxi
music concert. This is said to be THE ancient Chinese music. The average
age of the musicians was over 80! The music was used in ancient China
as part of an elaborate musical ritual. Followers of Confucius used
it to promote inner peace. The music would probably have been lost if
it weren't for one remarkable man. Xuan Ke grew up a rich kid who ended
up becoming conductor of the Kunming orchestra at age 23. His life seemed
to come to an end when the Dali Lama fled Tibet. Since Xuan Ke was a
distant relation (by marriage) to the Dali Lama he got 20+ years in
prison plus many years working in coal mines. Through it all he didn't
forget his Music or English. After he was freed he discovered the Naxi
music that was being played in small villages by old men. They had learned
it by ear passed down through generations. The music wasn't written
anywhere and would likely die with the current musicians. He put the
music to paper and spread the music with his good marketing and English
skills. The musicians have enjoyed international attention. They will
be a featured part of the Vienna 1999 new year's eve concert.
- Taking two camera bodies proved to be quite useful
especially when one jammed during the opening ceremonies. The rest of
the time having two allowed me to shoot freely without constantly changing
lenses.
- Land slides: The hills along roads are not shored
up very well. We saw a number of landslides including a couple with
rocks the size of mini-vans.
- Traffic Laws: Basically non-existent except for
the general guideline to stay to the right if there's oncoming traffic.
Enforcement of any rules appear to be arbitrary. Usually it's when the
police need to make some extra money. They'll come to an "agreement"
with the driver to not impact their driving record for small offenses.
We were stopped for passing a truck loaded with rock going up a hill
at about 5 mph. It happened to be a no passing zone and the police were
hiding behind a hill. Our driver negotiated the "fine" down to half
the asking by saying the truck appeared to be stopped or having problems.
They can stop you any time for any reason. We heard of instances of
stops for 'paper checks' and then requiring a check of the entire car.
Any offenses were negotiable.
- Tiger Leaping Gorge: The walls of this gorge between
two towering mountains are made of beautiful marble. It can clearly
be seen where the had just blasted away the hill side for a new road.
- This trip reinforced my prefferance for private/individual
travel but sometimes it's necessary. We had our own guide and driver
but I still prefer to drive myself which makes it easier to stop whenever
I want. I would have preferred to spend more time exploring a couple
of locations but there wasn't enough time.
- Almost every event was delayed while waiting for
Gov officials to arrive. Most things won't start until they're there
to watch.
- My digital camera (new toy) proved useful on a couple
occasions where subjects were apprehensive about having their picture
taken. Shooting a digital picture and showing them on the LCD screen
what it looks like is a good ice breaker. I had originally intended
to e-mail out some digital pix but the poor net connectivity changed
that.
- Credit cards weren't accepted anywhere we went.
Cash was the only option.
- Many of the hotels only have hot water 3-4 hours
per evening... that's it.
- I discovered a guaranteed weight reduction plan.
Just eat some food with bacteria. From personal experience I don't recommend
this plan!
- The service and hospitality was quite good for a
majority of our trip. The exception was any State run business which
offered very poor service and quality. The worst hotel we stayed in
was State run.
- Pirated CDs were seen everywhere. They were even
sold in traffic jams. Our driver bought a few video CDs while we were
stuck in traffic for only $2.25 each.
- When we stayed near a huge hydro-electric dam which
is under construction I questioned why the foreign (US & Europe) engineers
choose to live on the mountain top. We had to stay in town. Do they
know something we don't :-)? They live above the flood plain if the
dam breaks.
- Even mailing post cards to those without e-mail
was an experience. We went to the post office to buy stamps. The window
which sold stamps didn't have enough change and the worker wasn't willing
to get any. We had to go to a different window to get change and come
back. Then the stamps had no adhesive on them. We were confronted with
a large vat of liquid glue and chopsticks as applicators. Trying to
glue 3 stamps on each card proved to be quite messy. It took almost
20 minutes at the post office to mail 10 cards!
If you're interested in traveling to Yunnan check
out Yunnan Adventure
Travel company. Ask for Frank as your guide. He speaks excellent
English. Ask for Jack as your driver. Jack and Frank made our journey
quite enjoyable.
Suggested Yunnan Travel Guides
(Click on the book title to order directly from Amazon
Books)
Yunnan
This book is full of objective information on Yunnan. There aren't
many guide books that cover Yunnan. This guide is a must have if
you're planning on going!
China
Yunnan Province : The Best Travel Guide
This comprehensive guide is forthcoming. It will be published in
July 2001.
Lonely
Planet China
As with most Lonely Planet guides, this China edition is an invaluable
resource for planning your journey. It offers you the most up-to-date
information about where to go and where to aviod, how to get there
and get around, where to stay at a reasonable rate. The guide provides
everything you'll need to know for a rewarding visit.